The Joy of Motion in Non-Action Games

Motion has been a core part of the video game experience since it’s inception. The fundamental joy of pressing a button and seeing something move on your screen underpins everything we’d call a video game. For some games, motion is at the very essence of the experience. I’d like to talk about games where motion is not at the core, and how they can benefit from it anyway.

Point-and-click adventure games, visual novels, and many RPGs largely forsake motion in their gameplay, and often to their detriment. Hardcore fans of the genre may even take pride in the sparseness of action in these games, but just as many would-be players simply don’t have the patience to play a game where they never feel like they are moving–even if there is a deep and complex narrative world to explore, or a mentally stimulating gameplay mechanic to engage with.

In truth, for many players, exploration requires motion. Sailing a ship, hurtling through space, speeding down a highway, galloping along on a horse, soaring through the sky–these are mechanics often adopted by open world or otherwise exploration-oriented games to give a sense of space, and to capitalize on the joy of motion. And while most players will resort to fast traveling as soon as possible, I do remember a certain sense of freedom when, in Skyrim, I could afford a horse, and was ready to go anywhere I pleased, thus mounted.

This same principle can be applied to games that don’t have a huge open world to explore. Putting the sense of motion into exploration, and making the simple task of traveling from one place to another feel good, is something even a non-action, narrative-driven game can benefit from.

nitw2

A Note on Terminology

Throughout this article, I use the term “motive controls” to mean a game control scheme where the player directly controls a character on-screen, which has some dynamic motion capabilities, such as running, jumping, or flying. I would use “motion controls,” but that sounds too much like a virtual-reality-like convergence of human body motion and character motion. I don’t want to address human body motion as a game control scheme here; just the motion of game characters on a screen.

Motion in Non-Action Games

My poster-child for good motive gameplay in a non-action game is Infinite Fall’s acclaimed Night in the Woods, a side-scrolling platformer-style game centered on an anthropomorphic (and highly relatable) cat named Mae Borowski, a college dropout who has just returned to her rural hometown. While there are a few simple platforming puzzles, fundamentally Night in the Woods is not a platformer. The core gameplay is all narrative: you could remove the platforming entirely, and have a coherent Night in the Woods adventure game; but if you removed all the narrative, what’s left is not a playable platformer. That said, Night in the Woods does make excellent use of platforming as a means of traveling and exploring.

Boing boing boing
Exploration platforming in Infinite Fall’s Night in the Woods.

It’s a game where you visit the same places every day–various locales around the protagonist’s hometown, places where old friends live or work–with no fast travel system. Yet, it doesn’t feel like a total drag because the basic act of traversing the areas is fun. The controls aren’t super tight, like they would be in an action-platformer, making certain sequences feel clunky, but the basic sense of kinesthetic joy the player gets jumping from rooftop to rooftop and tiptoeing across telephone wires is there.

Night in the Woods does a great job placing content in locations that make active use of motive controls a necessary part of your travel and exploration: jumping and climbing allows you to reach little tidbits like a crew of baby rats in a loft, or a friendly astronomy teacher on a rooftop who shows you constellations with a telescope. The platforming challenges to reach these nuggets of content are not difficult, but that’s actually a good thing. What’s important is putting players in a position where exploration involves analyzing their surroundings and engaging with their environment, rather than simply taking time to search every available pathway.

Perhaps the most impressive aspect of the platforming in Night in the Woods is how cleanly it meshes with the visual aesthetic. The game nails a storybook-like art style which neatly arranges each area in two dimensions for platforming, while still conveying a strong sense of depth to the environment. The way characters move on the screen works well for both jumping around, and dialogue-heavy scenes. The failing in this area is that it is occasionally difficult to tell what is a platform and what is part of the background or foreground. At heart, the game puts good visuals before platforming clarity, but since the platforming is never terribly difficult to begin with, this doesn’t cause major issues.

Persona-5-Platforming
Platforming in Persona 5.

There are plenty of other games which try to get a little joy of motion in on the side. Persona 5, the newest entry in everyone’s favorite JRPG/dating sim fusion series, added stealth and platforming elements to dungeon exploration. When I first saw a trailer with the protagonist jumping across chandeliers and hiding from guards, I was pretty nervous. Persona is already, like, three games worth of mechanics rolled into one, and stealth-platforming is hard to get right when its the only gameplay. Turns out, my worries were largely unfounded. The high-motive gameplay in Persona 5 is pretty low-challenge: basically, press the X button, and something good will happen. The context-driven nature of the beast (it’s tricky to design stealth and platforming controls with only one button) made it occasionally awkward, but mostly it was just a way to make moving around your environment a little more interesting. The basic principle of this gameplay is not to add challenge, but allow the player to leap across chandeliers, dart out of hiding to ambush enemies, climb up and down multi-level areas, and look cool doing it.  The additional learning curve this feature adds to an already dense game, plus a certain clunkiness that rears it’s head in certain sequences, puts the motive controls in Persona 5 at a solid B grade, but I will admit to having some fun with them once I was acclimated.

Walking simulators are a ripe genre for use of motive controls in non-action games, as designers increasingly explore the narrative and visual potential of first-person games without gratuitous shootouts.  First-person controls can be deceptively tricky to nail, though, and when a developer takes the time to customize features like walking speed, head-bob, and running/jumping controls to their game rather than just plug-and-play with the cheapest first-person control script off the Unity asset store, it really shows.

parable1
The player on a moving platform in The Stanley Parable.

What I really want to talk about, though, is not the minutia of head-bobbing, but clever usage of first-person motion in a narrative game. I’ll use The Stanley Parable as a familiar example. A game that is principally about choice, one might think The Stanley Parable would work well as a point-and-click adventure or visual novel, where discretized choices are the core interactive mechanic. However, The Stanley Parable gains enormous benefits from using motive controls. The game never features any sort of HUD-based interactivity: every choice in the complex, branching narrative is made via character motion, underscoring the player’s agency in the story, one of the primary narrative themes. The Stanley Parable also does a good job hiding choices in way that involve the player moving in atypical ways, such as jumping off a platform at a certain time, or turning around and finding that the door behind them now leads somewhere different.  This organically forces the player to be alert and engage more actively with their surroundings.

The Stanley Parable also uses moving environments to effectively advance its narrative themes. At least twice in the game, the player finds themself on a moving platform: in one case, they’re being railroaded back towards the main path by an irked narrator, but have the option of leaping off to explore a different route; in the other, they’re on a conveyor belt in an industrial death trap, waiting to be crushed by unforgiving machinery. One situation emphasizes choice, the other is an embodiment of inevitability–two ideas that play tug-of-war throughout the entire game. The latter case shows off one of the most potent avenues opened by giving the player motive controls: what it feels like when you take them away.

NaissanceE
A strong sense of motion is conveyed in the opening sequence of Limasse Five’s NaissenceE as the protagonist sprints down a long hallway, fleeing an unknown danger.

So… High Motive Controls In Every Game?

Not necessarily. Pretty much every example of a non-action-oriented game with interesting motive controls comes with the caveat “it’s a little clunky at times, but…” Making sleek character controls that don’t feel or look clunky is hard. If you’re making a Metroidvania or bullet hell, smooth yet precise controls is, like, half the development process.  (Metroidvania or bullet hell developers can correct me on that percentage). All games are made with time and budget constraints, so if jumping, flying, or driving isn’t a necessary part of a game, it might not make sense to spend time and effort on these features.

Also, a game shouldn’t include motive controls just for the sake of it. They have to synergize with other gameplay, whether that’s exploration or puzzles or how dialogue plays out or just reinforcing the visual aesthetic of the game. Replacing what would be a direct cut with a motive travel sequence really doesn’t add much by itself.

When done wrong, motive controls can be a dealbreaker for a player, adding boring or frustrating sequences which distract from the core mechanics. When done right, though, they can increase player engagement and create a sense of wonder and exploration that’s hard to match with just point-and-click.

-Louis

PAX West ’17 Rundown

I was only at PAX West for one day.  Here are the highlights:

  • Heard the word “aftercare” used to mean dealing with emotional aftereffects of a high gravitas tabletop role-playing game.
  • Decided all of once to try waiting on line to do something in the expo hall, but the line was full.
  • Spent more time in the Indie Megabooth section of the expo hall than the rest combine.
  • Was reminded that the vast majority of games and gaming-related products hold zero interest for me.
  • Napped on a beanbag.
  • Was randomly given a cookie by a cute girl.
  • Saw Koji Igarashi but was too shy to introduce myself.
  • Saw Christine Love but was too shy to introduce myself.
  • Saw the entire staff of Extra Credits but was too shy to introduce myself.

So… all in all a success, would buy again.

New Project: Crown of Thorns

A side project I’m bringing to the front burner to try to get done, Crown of Thorns is a darkly atmospheric fantasy adventure game.

Players assume the role of Brunhilde, a mysterious and silent knight with an unknown mission at an empty castle.  Using magical portals, she goes back and forth between two versions of the castle: one pristine, the other decrepit and ruined, but both mysteriously deserted.  A foreboding presence pervades the ruined castle, causing strange distortions in the world.

Brunhilde must overcome various obstacles to clear the distortions, break through magical seals, and eventually reach the center of the castle, and its mystery.

The primary gameplay of Crown of Thorns is exploration and puzzles, where players must use both versions of the castle to overcome obstacles, in the vein of light world / dark world or past / present type puzzles seen in Zelda games and similar works.  There is no combat in Crown of Thorns, just mystery and exploration.

crown_of_thorns3

There is a lot of religious iconography in Crown of Thorns (in case the name didn’t tip you off).  Throughout the world, you will find (fictional) scriptural passages.  These texts tell of a religion that worships angelic figures called Graces, who brought divine gifts and moral guidance to humankind.  To you, their words serve as a backdrop to the slowly unraveling narrative, and as riddles that tell you how to get past various obstacles in the game.

More on this project as it comes along.  Hoping to have a playable beta available in a few weeks!

-Louis

Asteroidal Projection in Beta

Last winter, while stepping onto a bus, I had an idea for an Asteroids-like game that took place in the Poincaré Disk, a model of the hyperbolic plane best known for its use in M. C. Escher tessellation art.  Well, I haven’t followed through on that, because it would be hard to do.  Instead, I grabbed a much lower-hanging fruit which, to a layman observer, has a similar visual effect.

Thus was Asteroidal Projection born, an Asteroids-clone that takes place in normal Euclidean space, except with the plane compressed into a disk-shape.  Distances become increasingly distorted as you get farther from the center of the screen, with distant objects remaining visual, though warped, in the edges of the disk.  This visual distortion gives the illusion that the game is occurring on a curved, dome-like surface, but this is actually not the case.  Mathematically, the game world is topologically equivalent to the plane, and all the physics and collision detection occurs identically to how it would on a flat play area.  You can think of the game’s visuals as an alternative way of viewing flat space which keeps much more of the play area in view at once but does not preserve shape, distance, or angle.

For the topology/complex analysis nerds out there, the visuals in Asteroidal Projection are the image of the Euclidean plane through this homeomorphism:

equation

And yes, strictly speaking, this is not a projection, just the standard homeomorphism from the plane to the disk.  What can I say?  I didn’t think “Homeomorphic Asteroids” had the same ring to it.

Anyway, you can play it online here:

https://l-e-webb.github.io/asteroidal_projection

This “beta” is very informal, just drop me a line if you have any feedback!  (feedback@tangledwebgames.com)

-Louis

PS I still haven’t decided whether I’d rather use really minimalist, purely geometric visuals for this game.  What do you think?

 

The Blue Room in Beta

I’m pleased to announce that The Blue Room, an short adventure game about depression, anxiety, and loneliness, is now in open beta and available on itch.io:

https://tangledwebgames.itch.io/the-blue-room

The Blue Room is a room escape game, but instead of locked doors and puzzles, the true impediment to escape is the protagonist’s own depression and agoraphobia.  The central narrative of the game is framed by the two choices your character is given when you attempt to open your door and go outside: “No,” and “Nah.”  As you explore the room and learn more about the character’s past and daily life, you unlock more excuses for not going outside–“I’m too tired,” or “I’m not ready,” or just plain “I don’t want to.”  Throughout the game, the paralyzing effects of depression and anxiety are simulated for the player by the restrictive choices presented to them.

This is a deeply personal work for me, inspired by my own experiences, and those of people close to me.  Even when it moves out of beta into it’s final release, I will never charge money for The Blue Room.  I only hope that it raises awareness about how challenging depression can be, and engenders empathy in those who play it.

-Louis

New Project: Dreamquill

I’m pleased to announce my latest project, Dreamquill.  Made in RPGMaker is my take on the classic turn-based RPG genre.  Key features include:

  • A touching story of self-discovery centered around magic-wielding teens, including romance options and a variety of endings.
  • Determine the exact properties you want your spells to have in the midst of battle with an innovative spell-crafting system.
  • Beautiful dreamscapes to explore.
  • And, of course, plenty of monsters to beat, puzzles to solve, and treasures to find!

Story

Players assume the role of Skylar Chaudhri, age 17, one of the top students at Armistead Academy, a prestigious boarding school for aspiring runemages.  Along with two of her classmates, Skylar is assigned to investigate reports of strange goings-on in nearby Chantelune Forest, a place with a reputation for being mystical at best and downright haunted at worst.  Once inside, Skylar and company are attacked by monsters and separated.

Undaunted–well, okay, pretty daunted, but unwilling to give up, Skylar sets off on a quest to find her classmates and escape the forest.  She finds herself trekking through a strange world where past and present, truth and falsehood, reality and illusion seem to interweave seamlessly, and she is pitted against deadly monsters, obfuscating puzzles, and sometimes her companions or even herself.

What’s the cause of all this strangeness?  Can Skylar find her classmates?  And even if she does, will they survive to greet the dawn?

My recommendation is to combine Ice and Empower to cast Crystalize on that Fire Imp.

Battle System

Dreamquill features a turn-based combat system similar to classics like Final Fantasy.  However, instead of each character having a fixed list of spells or skill, in Dreamquill you form spells on the fly by combining runes.

Each character equips up to five runes, and runes are put together to form spells.  For example, the FireArrow, and All runes can be used to form the spell Hail of Fire Arrows, a powerful attack which damages all enemies.  The Poison and Shield runes can be used to cast the spell Poison Ward, which protects a character from the poison status ailment.  When you cast a spell, the runes used to do so will be on cooldown and unavailable next turn.

This system has a number gameplay benefits:

  • Rune combination adds depth in combat by allowing you to choose the exact spell effects for any situation, such as whether to target one or all enemies, what element to use, and how powerful the spell should be.
  • Each character can form a wide variety of spells based on the runes they equip, giving you a healthy amount of choice in battle.
  • You can freely rearrange runes between battle to find combinations that best suit the enemies you face.
  • Rune cooldown acts as a natural limitation on your spellcasting ability, removing the need for cumbersome resource bars such as MP.

Glittering thing. Stop ignoring the glittering thing.

Development Schedule

Dreamquill already has a playable prototype, and a good chunk of the art done or in the pipeline.  I hope to launch a Kickstarter campaign soon to raising enough money to commission the rest of the art assets.  From there, it will be approximately 3 months to a playable beta, then hopefully 3 more months to final release.

How so fast?  Well, the core game is already made.  From here on out it’s integrating art, fine-tuning gameplay, fixing bugs, and implementing changes based on eventual beta-user feedback.  In a relatively small-scale game, I hope this can happen quickly.  This promise may blow up in my face, but we can hope not.

-Louis

Blog Opening!

I’m happy to announce the grand opening of the new Tangled Web Games development blog!

Nothing to see here at the moment, but this is where I’ll post updates on the development of projects, as well as sneak-peaks at new art or features in the pipeline.  Enjoy!

-Louis